Review: The Debut – They’re all gonna laugh at this! - X-Press Magazine - Entertainment in Perth
CLOSE

Review: The Debut – They’re all gonna laugh at this!

Director by Jesse Eisenberg
Starring Julianne Moore, Paul Giamatti, Jesse Eisenberg

 9/10

Once again, the bizarre and lovable characters who inhabit the realm of community theatre are in the spotlight in the new comedy drama and semi-musical The Debut. The film boasts some wonderful original music coming from surprising musical theatre fan Jesse Eisenberg who directs and provides music for the play within a film: “Nosey Neighbours”.

Mona Friedman (Julianne Moore) is a neglected and ignored upper-class housewife living in the margins of her own life until she braves auditions for a play overseen by “the biggest name in New Jersey community theatre,” Jerry Blankenbuehler (Paul Giamatti). Whilst being greeted by the impossibly cheery and cartoonishly positive cast and crew, Jerry brute-forces his way through scenes and “Mocha, no milk” orders to see his vision fulfilled. With only second choice Mona left to fill the vital role of “Miss Danielle,” he is faced with the challenge of building something workable out of her bottled-up non-performance.

What follows is a hilarious boot camp of forcing the naïve and suppressed Mona into the horrors of the real world to “break her into pieces and put Humpty back together again.” Jerry is initially impressed at Mona’s surprising transformation, but she soon discovers an insatiable appetite for method acting to dig deeper into her character, hoping to impress the only people in her life who are gracing her with any attention, throwing her life and the production into unknown and dangerous territory.

What’s impressive about The Debut is how engaging and entertaining it is whilst resisting the temptation to continue pressing the characters into wilder, harsher extremes. A lesser film would have taken the character’s journeys towards the cliff and joyously watched them plummet to their gory demise, but Eisenberg forgoes those easy thrills to drill more conservatively for something more real within the unreal. Giamatti’s enigmatic jerk director Jerry is a classic diva theatre archetype, but the script pulls up before we see him reach the anticipated Whiplash level of psychotic cruelty.

Moore’s Mona is unhinged and unbalanced after getting a taste of independence, positive attention and praise, but she doesn’t wind up in Misery levels of depraved delusion, despite the trajectory seeming like she could reach those depths at some points. She shares an electrifying scene with Giamatti in an empty, darkened theatre as she is squeezed to breaking point by him to illicit a performance until she serves back a fiery retort in-character which rides a wave of suddenly-released suppressed energy. However, her quiet and subdued moments showcase a heartbreaking character conditioned by exclusion from conversation and thoughts by her family and friends and the longing for connection which is fostered by her theatre colleagues and her new endeavour.

Tonally it feels like it’s hit a sweet spot rarely landed by other filmmakers. Characters and situations feel reality bending, never breaking. Choreographer Andy Blankenbeuhler, famous for In the Heights and Hamilton, adjusts the calibre of his work for the film’s theatre show, which equates to “a good actor pretending to be an ok actor.” It’s believably moderate without looking clunky and silly, and paired with the music of Eisenberg’s fake play, the show we see unfold is convincingly real.

If anyone has dabbled in theatre or performance, there’s sure to be a lot of familiarity with some of these vivid characters and situations. If you like musicals, you’re gonna have a great time. If you think musicals are stupid, don’t worry! You’re also likely to have a great time. The love for musicals and theatre is plain to see here, as is the eye-rolling and knowing disdain.

JOHN HOLDCROFT

The Debut is playing as part of the Perth Festival Lotterywest Films at UWA Somerville from Monday, November 23 to Sunday, November 29, 2026. Tickets are on sale now from perthfestival.com.au

← x